Fatima leads the revolt
30 Apr 2012 09:59 #29025
by johannes
Replied by johannes on topic Re: Fatima leads the revolt
From what I gather the fundamental problem here is: you are not trying to do a Fatima deck. You are trying to do exactly THIS Fatima deck and you expect by some minor tweaks an will become very strong by miracle. That might be overstating it some, but I think it is really the core issue.
When you want to use Fatima effectively go back to the drawing board and analyze what makes Fatima good. She is an 8-cap from a sucky clan that can´t even diablerize with no bounce discipline. The ONLY thing that makes her worthwile is her special. So since that is the only thing she got going for her maybe you should think about getting more mileage out of it. Here special gets rid of the dependency on Concealed/Disguised Weapon. Using it once per game to equip a 5-pool equipment doesn´t make a lot of sense to me. If I was to build a Fatima deck I would have more useful support vampires in there who can Heidelberg or plain old get the weapons Fatima equips, and that she should do often so you need cheaper weapons (Ivory Bow, .44 ..).
Don´t rely on multirush, but rather rushing with 2-3 vampires. Capitalize on your CEL instead of needing to be Anarch to play those cards. I would think about dropping the whole Anarch angle (it really doesn´t make decks better usually) and concentrate on Assamites, using Loss, Fame and Dragonbound for ousting. Put some bloat in there (Khabar: Loyalty or Haqim's Law: Leadership OR Provision of the Silsila/Villein) and some defense (Nest of Eagles, Black Sunrise).
See I am not trying to make this a girls deck, but I think the concept needs a major overhaul.
When you want to use Fatima effectively go back to the drawing board and analyze what makes Fatima good. She is an 8-cap from a sucky clan that can´t even diablerize with no bounce discipline. The ONLY thing that makes her worthwile is her special. So since that is the only thing she got going for her maybe you should think about getting more mileage out of it. Here special gets rid of the dependency on Concealed/Disguised Weapon. Using it once per game to equip a 5-pool equipment doesn´t make a lot of sense to me. If I was to build a Fatima deck I would have more useful support vampires in there who can Heidelberg or plain old get the weapons Fatima equips, and that she should do often so you need cheaper weapons (Ivory Bow, .44 ..).
Don´t rely on multirush, but rather rushing with 2-3 vampires. Capitalize on your CEL instead of needing to be Anarch to play those cards. I would think about dropping the whole Anarch angle (it really doesn´t make decks better usually) and concentrate on Assamites, using Loss, Fame and Dragonbound for ousting. Put some bloat in there (Khabar: Loyalty or Haqim's Law: Leadership OR Provision of the Silsila/Villein) and some defense (Nest of Eagles, Black Sunrise).
See I am not trying to make this a girls deck, but I think the concept needs a major overhaul.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
30 Apr 2012 10:04 #29028
by Ohlmann
Replied by Ohlmann on topic Re: Fatima leads the revolt
As a fun idea on Fatima, use its special to get some wooden stake, and tremere support for Biothaumaturgic experiment ?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
01 May 2012 09:27 #29124
by Pendargon
Replied by Pendargon on topic Re: Fatima leads the revolt
@ Johannes
You are both right and wrong, if you would allow me to explain.
It is true, i want to play *this* Fatima deck. A deck that has fatima multirushing, and a deck that has anarch angle to it. Now, i do not expect miracles, nor did i ever claim this is THE deck to win european championship with. What i do think, is that the deck has some potential, and i am asking the community to help me make it better, if i missed something, and other important and valid suggestions.
Now, on one hand i got some really good and constructive suggestions like :
1. support cast could be better (be it weenie dom dudes, Ventrue or Trem support, whatever), or go all assamites and bloat with HL and Heartblooods.
2. Deck is seriously short on defensive potential apart form backrushing ( to be remedied in some way)
3. I missed some obvious cards (like crimethinc, Steely teenacity, blood turnip, Giant's blood).
Those are constructive advices. And there are non-constructive ones like Izaak's or yours (no offense, i hold great respect for you both as a player and a VEKN inner circle member, but i think your deck idea is not very good, i can explain it in a PM if you like, not to clutter the thread).
If i could draw a parallel here :
A week or so ago you posted on the forums a lovely !Nos rush combat deck, and asked people to take a look at it and comment. It is a really nice deck, with its strengths and weaknesses (very fun to play, i tried it).
Now, imagine me commenting on it like this :
"Hey, Johannes, it is nice that you tried !Nos combat, but combat sucks and you have to backrush sometimes. So, i would ditch all combat module, all deep songs, preter strengths and Heroic mights, and all the red cards. You are playing !Nos with dominate, here, hey!!! It is better to instead of all that, you put in Governs and Conditionings and a nice obfuscate stealth package, and another Enkil cog or two. Then, stack on permanent intercept with raven spies and abbots, and then block people with animalism untaps and Eternal vigilance and play obedience!!! That will help you utilize enkil cog more with dominate bleeds. And toss in a majesty or two as a surprise effect, nobody expects this from Cailean. That is a much better deck, when you analyze Cailean as a Vampire... "
See... That was not very constructive at all ^^^^^, now...
So unless my point is not clear : when i post a deck idea, it is because i would like the community to help me work that idea to the best of that ideas limited possibilities ie. Make best possible Fatima rush deck with anarch angle, because that is what i want to take to my regular saturday night gaming night this week. Saying : that sucks, go make something else is really helping nobody here
You are both right and wrong, if you would allow me to explain.
It is true, i want to play *this* Fatima deck. A deck that has fatima multirushing, and a deck that has anarch angle to it. Now, i do not expect miracles, nor did i ever claim this is THE deck to win european championship with. What i do think, is that the deck has some potential, and i am asking the community to help me make it better, if i missed something, and other important and valid suggestions.
Now, on one hand i got some really good and constructive suggestions like :
1. support cast could be better (be it weenie dom dudes, Ventrue or Trem support, whatever), or go all assamites and bloat with HL and Heartblooods.
2. Deck is seriously short on defensive potential apart form backrushing ( to be remedied in some way)
3. I missed some obvious cards (like crimethinc, Steely teenacity, blood turnip, Giant's blood).
Those are constructive advices. And there are non-constructive ones like Izaak's or yours (no offense, i hold great respect for you both as a player and a VEKN inner circle member, but i think your deck idea is not very good, i can explain it in a PM if you like, not to clutter the thread).
If i could draw a parallel here :
A week or so ago you posted on the forums a lovely !Nos rush combat deck, and asked people to take a look at it and comment. It is a really nice deck, with its strengths and weaknesses (very fun to play, i tried it).
Now, imagine me commenting on it like this :
"Hey, Johannes, it is nice that you tried !Nos combat, but combat sucks and you have to backrush sometimes. So, i would ditch all combat module, all deep songs, preter strengths and Heroic mights, and all the red cards. You are playing !Nos with dominate, here, hey!!! It is better to instead of all that, you put in Governs and Conditionings and a nice obfuscate stealth package, and another Enkil cog or two. Then, stack on permanent intercept with raven spies and abbots, and then block people with animalism untaps and Eternal vigilance and play obedience!!! That will help you utilize enkil cog more with dominate bleeds. And toss in a majesty or two as a surprise effect, nobody expects this from Cailean. That is a much better deck, when you analyze Cailean as a Vampire... "
See... That was not very constructive at all ^^^^^, now...
So unless my point is not clear : when i post a deck idea, it is because i would like the community to help me work that idea to the best of that ideas limited possibilities ie. Make best possible Fatima rush deck with anarch angle, because that is what i want to take to my regular saturday night gaming night this week. Saying : that sucks, go make something else is really helping nobody here
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
01 May 2012 10:22 #29130
by johannes
Hmm I thought my advice was constructive, I mean you don´t have to do all of it. Haqim`s Law: Leadership for example still works nicely with multi-act. You could also take the idea of having more useful support minions by making them, say, for/cel minions and have the cheaper weapons.
May main points being that the deck would be much better when:
- Capitalizing more on Fatima´s special (cheaper weapons)
- Eventually having a second minion to rush
It is always hard to know which level of change you are looking for. I usually look for more substantial changes than single cards so I tend to be on the extreme side
Replied by johannes on topic Re: Fatima leads the revolt
Those are constructive advices. And there are non-constructive ones like Izaak's or yours (no offense, i hold great respect for you both as a player and a VEKN inner circle member, but i think your deck idea is not very good, i can explain it in a PM if you like, not to clutter the thread).
Hmm I thought my advice was constructive, I mean you don´t have to do all of it. Haqim`s Law: Leadership for example still works nicely with multi-act. You could also take the idea of having more useful support minions by making them, say, for/cel minions and have the cheaper weapons.
May main points being that the deck would be much better when:
- Capitalizing more on Fatima´s special (cheaper weapons)
- Eventually having a second minion to rush
It is always hard to know which level of change you are looking for. I usually look for more substantial changes than single cards so I tend to be on the extreme side
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
01 May 2012 11:05 #29135
by Pendargon
Replied by Pendargon on topic Re: Fatima leads the revolt
Fair enough 
Think this is the version that will be tried out. Dom weenies for deflection and to bleed out the prey with Steely Tenacities at dom when Fatima (hopefully) clears the ready region :
Crypt [12 vampires]
4x Fatima al-Faqadi
4x Anarch Convert
1x Christine Boscacci
1x Samson
1x Ohanna
1x Mustafa Rahman
Library [80 cards]
Action [12]
3x Steely Tenacity
1x Bum's Rush
4x Clandestine Contract
1x Khabar: Glory
2x Nose of the Hound
1x Loss
Action Modifier [8]
4x Forced March
4x Freak Drive
Action Modifier/Combat [4]
4x Swallowed by the Night
Action Modifier/Reaction [2]
2x Provision of the Silsila
Combat [23]
7x Diversion
4x Groundfighting
8x Psyche!
4x Taste of Vitae
Equipment [8]
6x Assault Rifle
1x Ivory Bow
1x Blade of Enoch
Reaction : [6]
1x Delaying tactics
5x Deflection
Event [1]
1x Dragonbound
Master [16]
5x Anarch Revolt
2x Vessel
1x Fortitude
1x Monster
1x Dreams of the Sphinx
2x Fame
1x Tension in the ranks
1x Wider View
1x Twilight Camp
1x Seattle Comitee
Think this is the version that will be tried out. Dom weenies for deflection and to bleed out the prey with Steely Tenacities at dom when Fatima (hopefully) clears the ready region :
Crypt [12 vampires]
4x Fatima al-Faqadi
4x Anarch Convert
1x Christine Boscacci
1x Samson
1x Ohanna
1x Mustafa Rahman
Library [80 cards]
Action [12]
3x Steely Tenacity
1x Bum's Rush
4x Clandestine Contract
1x Khabar: Glory
2x Nose of the Hound
1x Loss
Action Modifier [8]
4x Forced March
4x Freak Drive
Action Modifier/Combat [4]
4x Swallowed by the Night
Action Modifier/Reaction [2]
2x Provision of the Silsila
Combat [23]
7x Diversion
4x Groundfighting
8x Psyche!
4x Taste of Vitae
Equipment [8]
6x Assault Rifle
1x Ivory Bow
1x Blade of Enoch
Reaction : [6]
1x Delaying tactics
5x Deflection
Event [1]
1x Dragonbound
Master [16]
5x Anarch Revolt
2x Vessel
1x Fortitude
1x Monster
1x Dreams of the Sphinx
2x Fame
1x Tension in the ranks
1x Wider View
1x Twilight Camp
1x Seattle Comitee
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
01 May 2012 12:00 #29140
by Azel
Replied by Azel on topic Re: Fatima leads the revolt
I think another question to add to the sticky checklist would be "What parts of the deck are crucial to theme or experiment?" Which would avoid confusion like this in the future. There is a difference between aspiring to a more competitive deck in general v. a more competitive version of a particular experiment.
By the way, I haven't heard all that great success with Dragonbound. I heard the hand anchor generally isn't worth it. How badly do you need to have the right hand setup?
I don't know how much you really need that Seattle Committee or Fortitude master. Do you need sup Freak or sup Forced March that badly? An extra Vessel for your weenies to farm pool for you seems more productive.
How prevalent is Scourge of the Enochians? Is this just a test, because I'd try dom tha weenies soon, as so many of them are 3+ cap. Being able to Magic of the Smith out an Assault Rifle sounds sweet. Then you can toss a CrimethInc to see if you have the pool for it. They'd also run off of your Diversions as a defensive combat card. I think it's a more engaging experiment than seeing whether dom weenies can deflect your sorrows away.
By the way, I haven't heard all that great success with Dragonbound. I heard the hand anchor generally isn't worth it. How badly do you need to have the right hand setup?
I don't know how much you really need that Seattle Committee or Fortitude master. Do you need sup Freak or sup Forced March that badly? An extra Vessel for your weenies to farm pool for you seems more productive.
How prevalent is Scourge of the Enochians? Is this just a test, because I'd try dom tha weenies soon, as so many of them are 3+ cap. Being able to Magic of the Smith out an Assault Rifle sounds sweet. Then you can toss a CrimethInc to see if you have the pool for it. They'd also run off of your Diversions as a defensive combat card. I think it's a more engaging experiment than seeing whether dom weenies can deflect your sorrows away.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.068 seconds
- You are here:
-
Home
-
Forum
-
V:TES Discussion
-
Deck Clinic
- Fatima leads the revolt
