Do I get to see the replaced card?

Hi folks,
maybe the answer is obvious, but if in doubt, ask for enlightenment! B-)

Revelations
+1 stealth action.
[aus] Look at your prey's hand. He or she discards a card of your choice.

Le Dinh Tho
Tho may look at another Methuselah's hand and discard one card from it as a +1 stealth action (that Methuselah draws back up to his or her hand size).

Question: Do I get to see the replaced card at the end of the action in both cases?

Thanks in advance!

Hakuron wrote:

Revelations
+1 stealth action.
[aus] Look at your prey's hand. He or she discards a card of your choice.

[LSJ 20100109]

LSJ wrote:

> 1) When player looks at prays hand using Revelations, and then
> discards a card, can he also see which card is drawn to replace it?
No.

Le Dinh Tho
Tho may look at another Methuselah's hand and discard one card from it as a +1 stealth action (that Methuselah draws back up to his or her hand size).

[LSJ 20030721]

LSJ wrote:

> 1. When Le Dinh Tho uses his ability to look at another Methuselah's
> hand and make them discard a card, does Le Dinh Tho's controller get
> to see the card that replaces the discarded one?
No.

I agree. Neither card allows you to see the player's hand for a discrete period phase, so it is very temporary.

Well the way we play is No... what we did have an argument about once was wether or not you HAD to discard one of her cards or not? Any thoughts on that?

delangen wrote:

Well the way we play is No... what we did have an argument about once was wether or not you HAD to discard one of her cards or not? Any thoughts on that?

[LSJ 20020107]

LSJ wrote:

> 1/ Le Dinh Tho: Independent: Tho may look at another Methuselah's hand and
> discard one card from it as a +1 stealth action (that Methuselah draws
> back up to his or her hand size). He gets -1 stealth when hunting. Scarce.
>
> His action allows for 2 things: look at your Prey's cards AND discard 1. Can
> you choose not to make him discard one?
No.

Revelations works the same way. The only way you can avoid making them discard a card is if they have no cards in their hand.