Gary Chatterton again ?

It's a matter of taste really. Personally I find it on the top 5 of my "I hate this crap" list. Plus - the old FoM was just waaaaaay more cool.

Ankha wrote:

1up20x6 wrote:

Personally, I think his Thaumaturgy, Obtenebration, and Obedience look better than the originals.

He hasn't done any of these cards.

vtes.pl/card/395549
vtes.pl/card/395507
vtes.pl/card/395506

Boy, last time I see the first two cards in an image are by him and assume that all of the others are too.

In this case, yes, he has no place designing cards for V:TES.

When I play his Bum's Rush or Depravity it is only to add insult to injury.



"I rush you with bad artwork. Deal with it!"

While not everyone may love some of those cards (Tha, Obt, etc)... He is responsible for some really below-par photo-shopping junk... But to my mind he sits on just one step below Shy's 4,000-vampires-of-same-ness...

Juggernaut1981 wrote:

While not everyone may love some of those cards (Tha, Obt, etc)... He is responsible for some really below-par photo-shopping junk... But to my mind he sits on just one step below Shy's 4,000-vampires-of-same-ness...

I can relate to that, yes - Shy had a number of really bad artworks (like, seriously - Ur-Shulgi is just ridiculously bad). However, he did have some good ones as well, especially in the Sabbat / SW times. He made my favorite group of !salubri (I can't stand the g4 vampires), generally the Bloodlines vamps he made were not bad either. It's just that as time passed he got more and more repetitive and didn't seem to care much. I still enjoy his older V:TES artworks though.