Summon History

Suoli wrote:

Or because you top decked your only target with a cost of 3 after announcing the action.

Which is absolutely AGAINST the rules, as you have to announce the action in all details BEFORE you redraw. This is one of the biggest mistakes made out there.

Joscha wrote:

Suoli wrote:

Or because you top decked your only target with a cost of 3 after announcing the action.

Which is absolutely AGAINST the rules, as you have to announce the action in all details BEFORE you redraw. This is one of the biggest mistakes made out there.

I think Suoli and you are talking about the same thing. In Suoli's example, there is one card costing 3 in the deck (say Helicopter). His vampire plays Summon History, announces X=3 (aiming for a Helicopter).
But then, he replaces SM by drawing Helicopter, so he's going to have to put something cheaper in play.

There's no mistake there.

Pascal wrote:

Joscha wrote:

Suoli wrote:

Or because you top decked your only target with a cost of 3 after announcing the action.

Which is absolutely AGAINST the rules, as you have to announce the action in all details BEFORE you redraw. This is one of the biggest mistakes made out there.

I think Suoli and you are talking about the same thing. In Suoli's example, there is one card costing 3 in the deck (say Helicopter). His vampire plays Summon History, announces X=3 (aiming for a Helicopter).
But then, he replaces SM by drawing Helicopter, so he's going to have to put something cheaper in play.

There's no mistake there.

Ah, okay. Sorry Suoli then. I have seen too many people playing without correct announcement or changing their announcement afterwards that I jumped on this issue too fast. We recently had a greater discussion on this topic on the german forum.

I'm pretty sure that whatever blood cost you announce, as long as it's 2 or more people will assume you fetch an Ankara

Pascal wrote:

Joscha wrote:

Suoli wrote:

Or because you top decked your only target with a cost of 3 after announcing the action.

Which is absolutely AGAINST the rules, as you have to announce the action in all details BEFORE you redraw. This is one of the biggest mistakes made out there.

I think Suoli and you are talking about the same thing. In Suoli's example, there is one card costing 3 in the deck (say Helicopter). His vampire plays Summon History, announces X=3 (aiming for a Helicopter).
But then, he replaces SM by drawing Helicopter, so he's going to have to put something cheaper in play.

There's no mistake there.

This regulary happens to me .

There's this trick a nice lady from Atlanta told me once.
First you get Heart of Cheating and then you never get those ugly surprises.