Title Issues

Hey y'all. Some players that I'm currently playing with currently don't believe me when I tell them that Specific City Titles Contest across the board. IE. Prince of X and Archbishop of X would contest titles if both were out. But according to this group, the only time contestation occurs is when someone from the same sect tries to take the Title. I've looked for a ruling on this but can't seem to find anything. So, I could use a little assist. Thank you.

Thanks, i couldn't find it previously.

Actually, the part you quote is not very clear. It could be understood as only princes contest with princes. You have to go to Section 10 to see the clarification:

10.1. Camarilla

One of the major sects is the Camarilla, which is composed of six clans: Brujah, Malkavian, Nosferatu, Toreador, Tremere and Ventrue, as well as the Caitiff, who are technically clanless. Some vampire cards from older sets do not have any sect designation -- these vampires are all Camarilla vampires.

Only Camarilla vampires can hold the Camarilla titles primogen, prince, justicar and Inner Circle member. Additionally, each clan's justicar and Inner Circle titles are unique (see Contested Titles, sec. 4.2) and can only be held by vampires of that clan. The title of prince is associated with a particular city and can be contested by another vampire who claims any title to the same city. The title of primogen is not unique and cannot be contested.

(Emphasis mine).

Maybe that sentence would fit better Section 4.2?

Yup, any title associated with a particular city will contest with any other title (be it Prince, Archbishop or Baron) of the same city.