Does Catatonic Fear + Target Vitals work?

I don't think I agree Ankha; You can, for example, Dodge both of these 'Strikes' even as they Combat Ends. You don't Dodge environmental, you can Dodge Loving Agony, I believe.

Combat still ends, the LA Vampire may still untap, but the opposing minion can Dodge the damage as their Strike.

(I think this is the only place this applies, Dawn Op would make it aggravated whether it's environmental or not, you can't Disarm from either card, and you can't prevent either anyway, so whether it's environment or not might be moot after that point.)

Shockwave wrote:

You don't Dodge environmental.

You're sure ? You don't dodge Carrion, but it's not because they are environnemental, it's because it's not a strike. I don't see any mention in the rule that let believe environnemental damage have any influence on dodge either.

I think we can afford a new topic in the Rules section for things that are not related to "Catatonic Fear + Target vitals"

Shockwave wrote:

I don't think I agree Ankha; You can, for example, Dodge both of these 'Strikes' even as they Combat Ends. You don't Dodge environmental, you can Dodge Loving Agony, I believe.

Combat still ends, the LA Vampire may still untap, but the opposing minion can Dodge the damage as their Strike.

(I think this is the only place this applies, Dawn Op would make it aggravated whether it's environmental or not, you can't Disarm from either card, and you can't prevent either anyway, so whether it's environment or not might be moot after that point.)

Actually, I would suggest that the only reason why you can't Disarm after Catatonic Fear is purely because the combat is over (and you can't play Disarm) and not because of the requirements of Disarm (beyond the fact it is a combat card).

Link is redirected to the new Google groups page.

edminister wrote:

Link is redirected to the new Google groups page.

Which link? The one Reyda provided, or the mine afterwards?
They both point to the same page, but the phpbb module on the forum "ends" the link at the # character in Reyda's post.