Hide the heart, timing question
18 Jun 2014 00:38 #63197
by Jesper
Hide the heart, timing question was created by Jesper
Vampire A with one blood bleeds with a govern bleed.
No one blocks, action is right now sucessfull
Vampire A pays the one blood, due to the action being succesfull
The impulse now goes around before damage are taken - this window need to be there to play e.g. Major Boon
Vampire B plays a Hide the heart in this window
Vampire A cannot pay, due to having already paid the one he have
Question one, is there anything preventing this play?
Question two, if not, what would then happen, is the action succesfull or not?
/Jesper
No one blocks, action is right now sucessfull
Vampire A pays the one blood, due to the action being succesfull
The impulse now goes around before damage are taken - this window need to be there to play e.g. Major Boon
Vampire B plays a Hide the heart in this window
Vampire A cannot pay, due to having already paid the one he have
Question one, is there anything preventing this play?
Question two, if not, what would then happen, is the action succesfull or not?
/Jesper
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
18 Jun 2014 03:56 #63202
by Ylly
Replied by Ylly on topic Re: Hide the heart, timing question
Inferior valeren says:
The action ends (unsuccessfully). The acting minion may burn 1 blood to cancel this card as it is played.
The vampire A in your example has no blood, cannot burn a blood to cancel Hide the Heart, so according to the card text, the action should be unsuccessful.
Is that correct?
The action ends (unsuccessfully). The acting minion may burn 1 blood to cancel this card as it is played.
The vampire A in your example has no blood, cannot burn a blood to cancel Hide the Heart, so according to the card text, the action should be unsuccessful.
Is that correct?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
18 Jun 2014 04:35 #63205
by Ankha
Correct sequence is:
A bleeds with Govern the Unaligned
B declines to block.
A declines to play modifiers.
B plays Hide the Heart.
A can pay 1 blood to cancel Hide the Heart
- if he does and doesn't gain blood until the end of the action, the action fizzles
- if he doesn't, action ends unsuccessfully per Hide the Heart's cardtext.
Replied by Ankha on topic Re: Hide the heart, timing question
If the action is successful and has resolved (pay cost, apply effect), it's too late to make it fail.Vampire A with one blood bleeds with a govern bleed.
No one blocks, action is right now sucessfull
Vampire A pays the one blood, due to the action being succesfull
The impulse now goes around before damage are taken - this window need to be there to play e.g. Major Boon
Vampire B plays a Hide the heart in this window
Correct sequence is:
A bleeds with Govern the Unaligned
B declines to block.
A declines to play modifiers.
B plays Hide the Heart.
A can pay 1 blood to cancel Hide the Heart
- if he does and doesn't gain blood until the end of the action, the action fizzles
- if he doesn't, action ends unsuccessfully per Hide the Heart's cardtext.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
18 Jun 2014 06:43 #63207
by jamesatzephyr
Yes, the rules.
If the action is successful, you are no longer "before resolution".
Replied by jamesatzephyr on topic Re: Hide the heart, timing question
Question one, is there anything preventing this play?
Yes, the rules.
Action modifiers and reaction cards can be played at any time before resolution during an action (unless otherwise noted on card text), with the acting Methuselah getting the opportunity to play first.
If the action is successful, you are no longer "before resolution".
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- jamesatzephyr
- Offline
- Antediluvian
Less
More
- Posts: 2788
- Thank you received: 958
Time to create page: 0.079 seconds
- You are here:
- Home
- Forum
- V:TES Discussion
- Rules Questions
- Hide the heart, timing question