file Is inferior Pulse of the Canaille a directed action

29 Oct 2026 22:23 #118013 by inm8
These are LSJ´s own words " The inferior is grammatically incorrect, mixing singular and plural for the target."

How it works isn't in question, but who, if any it targets... According to LSJ there are targets (plural); according to you, there are none...

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
01 Nov 2026 11:51 - 01 Nov 2026 11:51 #118032 by Hobbesgoblin
In jyhad it was clearly an undirected action

> Here's the card text:
>
> (BOLD) +1 stealth
> (not bold) Look at all Methusalh's hands for the remainder
> of your turn
> (BOLD) The acting vampire has 3 bleed for the remainder
> of the game
>
> My question: is the superior at +1 stealth as well?

Yes. Bold at the top applies to the entire card.

(Also all undirected actions are at stealth - with the exception
of Igo's hunting and the mis-printed superior Enchant Kindred).

usenet.krcg.org/t/FQZwLDHXFD4/#m2

this was from 1995 though, long before the changes to firected actions in KoT
Last edit: 01 Nov 2026 11:51 by Hobbesgoblin.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
02 Nov 2026 18:52 - 02 Nov 2026 19:06 #118046 by inm8
If the basis for the statement that it was "clearly undirected" is the quoted statement by LSJ, I'm not sure it holds.

LSJ wasn´t RD at the time when making the statement, and it was dismissed by the at the time RD Thomas R Wylie.

(Also all undirected actions are at stealth - with the exception
of Igo's hunting and the mis-printed superior Enchant Kindred).

Random non-directed actions do not default to being at any kind of stealth,
actually. They are assumed to be at 0 stealth, and it just so happens
that almost all of them are printed as being at +1 stealth. That is
not reminder text, that is a case of cards systematically breaking the
rules. An analagous situation would be mana sources in Magic... only
tapping lands for mana defaults to being an interrupt, and it just so
happens that most non-land sources of mana say the ability is played as
an interrupt. Such cards are not restating the rules, but systematically
breaking them.

Igo is breaking the rules, because hunting normally happens at +1 stealth,
so the card denotes this. Enchant Kindred is following the normal rules
for random actions, so does not need to print any kind of stealth value,
and is thus at 0 stealth. You might not *like* the fact that it's not at
+1 stealth, but that does not make it a misprint.

usenet.krcg.org/t/FQZwLDHXFD4/#m8

The contradiction for me, whether it is directed or not, is the fact that it is an effect that enables the player to access information about other players' hands (that normally is secret and not allowed to be disclosed/shared), which makes it strange not to be considered as targeting said hands, as that is part of what those players control (the cards and the information of their hand)
Last edit: 02 Nov 2026 19:06 by inm8.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
03 Nov 2026 00:08 #118048 by XZealot
It is a directed action.
It is almost identical to Vaticination

Vaticination

+3 stealth action.
Ⓓ Look at each Methuselah's hand and discard a card of your choice from among all those hands (including your own hand).

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
03 Nov 2026 18:20 - 03 Nov 2026 18:21 #118050 by Ankha

It is a directed action.
It is almost identical to Vaticination

Vaticination

+3 stealth action.
Ⓓ Look at each Methuselah's hand and discard a card of your choice from among all those hands (including your own hand).

"Almost" could make the difference.

Consider the card effect "+1 stealth action. Until the end of the turn, vampires can burn 1 blood to burn 1 life from all allies."

Would it be directed at all the vampires? All the allies? Or is it a generic effect?

(replace "vampires" by "you" and "allies" by "all Methuselahs' hands")

I'm still thinking about it.

Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
Last edit: 03 Nov 2026 18:21 by Ankha.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
Moderators: Ankha, Kraus
Time to create page: 0.064 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum