Presses outside of the press step
20 Jan 2015 21:38 #68745
by XZealot
Presses outside of the press step was created by XZealot
Can you use cards or effects to gain presses outside of the press step?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
20 Jan 2015 21:55 #68748
by chrisn101
Replied by chrisn101 on topic Re: Presses outside of the press step
Hi XZealot,
Do you mean like if you play superior Vampiric Speed as a strike?
Strike: dodge.
Strike: dodge, with an optional press.
Then yes. At press step, you can also play cards that specifically allow you to press e.g. Nimble Feet .
However, "A maneuver or press gained by a combat card can only be used during the current round of combat. A maneuver or press gained by a non-combat card (e.g., action, equipment) can be used in any round of the combat. [TOM 19960521]". Also, your minion can't press to continue and then press to end.
Do you mean like if you play superior Vampiric Speed as a strike?
Strike: dodge.
Strike: dodge, with an optional press.
Then yes. At press step, you can also play cards that specifically allow you to press e.g. Nimble Feet .
However, "A maneuver or press gained by a combat card can only be used during the current round of combat. A maneuver or press gained by a non-combat card (e.g., action, equipment) can be used in any round of the combat. [TOM 19960521]". Also, your minion can't press to continue and then press to end.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
20 Jan 2015 22:20 - 20 Jan 2015 22:21 #68749
by Pagan
Replied by Pagan on topic Re: Presses outside of the press step
No, the question came up with:
Name: Terry
[BL:U1]
Cardtype: Vampire
Clan: Blood Brother
Group: 2
Capacity: 5
Discipline: aus dom san POT
Sabbat. Chicago Circle: Once each combat, Terry can burn 1 blood to get a press. Sterile.
Artist: Christopher Shy
I wanted to burn a blood before strikes so he'd go to 0 and then torpor with damage. But intuitively we agree it isn't legal as no one cycles 15 presses during combat before the press step so there has to be a ruling somewhere that states this.
But after looking at the rulebook I can't find where it states you can only gain presses during the press step or a specific card ruling but it has to be there somewhere. Also it has to be a ruling his text doesn't 'Golden Rule' over.
Name: Terry
[BL:U1]
Cardtype: Vampire
Clan: Blood Brother
Group: 2
Capacity: 5
Discipline: aus dom san POT
Sabbat. Chicago Circle: Once each combat, Terry can burn 1 blood to get a press. Sterile.
Artist: Christopher Shy
I wanted to burn a blood before strikes so he'd go to 0 and then torpor with damage. But intuitively we agree it isn't legal as no one cycles 15 presses during combat before the press step so there has to be a ruling somewhere that states this.
But after looking at the rulebook I can't find where it states you can only gain presses during the press step or a specific card ruling but it has to be there somewhere. Also it has to be a ruling his text doesn't 'Golden Rule' over.
Last edit: 20 Jan 2015 22:21 by Pagan.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
21 Jan 2015 09:02 #68755
by jamesatzephyr
Well, the rulebook only talks about playing presses during the press step, 6.4.4, which implies it.
However, it has been explicitly ruled in the past that cards giving you an immediate press should be played in the press step. e.g. [LSJ 20070525]
And from two posts further on:
Similarly, you can only play immediate maneuvers in Choose Range and not in "before range is determined". You can only play an immediate additional strike after strikes are resolved. You can only play immediate damage prevention if there is damage to prevent. You can only play an immediate strike during Choose Strike.
As already noted, if a card gives you a press that is obviously for later e.g. Vampiric Speed, Flash, then you can play that earlier. If a card gives you a strike for later (e.g. superior Mythic Form), you can play that earlier. If a card gives you lingering damage prevention (e.g. Apparition) you can play that earlier. Additional strike later this round, Vial of Garou Blood.
Replied by jamesatzephyr on topic Re: Presses outside of the press step
But after looking at the rulebook I can't find where it states you can only gain presses during the press step or a specific card ruling but it has to be there somewhere. Also it has to be a ruling his text doesn't 'Golden Rule' over.
Well, the rulebook only talks about playing presses during the press step, 6.4.4, which implies it.
However, it has been explicitly ruled in the past that cards giving you an immediate press should be played in the press step. e.g. [LSJ 20070525]
> Immortal Grapple has a draft effect "[obf]Press". Considering the bold
> text "Only usable at close range before strikes are chosen. Grapple",
> when the draft effect should be played? If it should be played before
> strikes are chosen, why the text isn't like "This vampire gets an
> optional press this round", as usual?
Play in the press step.
And from two posts further on:
you can't play a press in the pre-range step.
Similarly, you can only play immediate maneuvers in Choose Range and not in "before range is determined". You can only play an immediate additional strike after strikes are resolved. You can only play immediate damage prevention if there is damage to prevent. You can only play an immediate strike during Choose Strike.
As already noted, if a card gives you a press that is obviously for later e.g. Vampiric Speed, Flash, then you can play that earlier. If a card gives you a strike for later (e.g. superior Mythic Form), you can play that earlier. If a card gives you lingering damage prevention (e.g. Apparition) you can play that earlier. Additional strike later this round, Vial of Garou Blood.
The following user(s) said Thank You: BenPeal
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- jamesatzephyr
- Offline
- Antediluvian
Less
More
- Posts: 2788
- Thank you received: 958
21 Jan 2015 11:10 #68757
by Pascal Bertrand
Replied by Pascal Bertrand on topic Re: Presses outside of the press step
Correct answer from jamesatzehpyr.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Pascal Bertrand
- Offline
- Moderator
Less
More
- Posts: 4268
- Thank you received: 1185
02 Feb 2015 22:11 #69029
by Pagan
Replied by Pagan on topic Re: Presses outside of the press step
So why is this not true then?
Terry contradicts the rules by allowing him to gain a press by burning a blood with the only restriction that he has to be in combat. The rulebook says when card text would allow something different than the rules, the card text wins.
If the intent is as explained above that he shouldn't be able to gain a press earlier Terry should then say,
And the rulebook needs to specify when a Press can be played and not require finding a ruling on a basic mechanic.
1.4. The Golden Rule for Cards
Whenever the cards contradict the rules, the cards take precedence.
Terry contradicts the rules by allowing him to gain a press by burning a blood with the only restriction that he has to be in combat. The rulebook says when card text would allow something different than the rules, the card text wins.
If the intent is as explained above that he shouldn't be able to gain a press earlier Terry should then say,
Once during the press step each combat, Terry can burn 1 blood to get a press.
And the rulebook needs to specify when a Press can be played and not require finding a ruling on a basic mechanic.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.096 seconds
- You are here:
- Home
- Forum
- V:TES Discussion
- Rules Questions
- Presses outside of the press step