What exactly is "Block resolution"
28 May 2019 09:04 - 28 May 2019 09:28 #95092
by Tadori
What exactly is "Block resolution" was created by Tadori
Its my first post here so I would like to say Hello to everyone. I'm returning to VETS after a long time in torpor.
I have the following question.
I found ont VEKN.NET in General rulings this rule:
"Combat occurs as part of the block - not after the block. (So Cats' Guidance and Freak Drive are played after the combat, not before). [RTR 19980623]"
In the new print of Change of target we have this statement "Only usable if this minion is blocked, before block resolution."
So looking on those two rules. You can play change of target after block attempt is successful and blocking vampire is locked.
I know the ruling of change of target is different but in this case what "Block resolution" actually mean
I have the following question.
I found ont VEKN.NET in General rulings this rule:
"Combat occurs as part of the block - not after the block. (So Cats' Guidance and Freak Drive are played after the combat, not before). [RTR 19980623]"
In the new print of Change of target we have this statement "Only usable if this minion is blocked, before block resolution."
So looking on those two rules. You can play change of target after block attempt is successful and blocking vampire is locked.
I know the ruling of change of target is different but in this case what "Block resolution" actually mean
Last edit: 28 May 2019 09:28 by Tadori.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
28 May 2019 09:40 - 28 May 2019 09:49 #95094
by Ankha
Replied by Ankha on topic What exactly is "Block resolution"
From the latest newsletter:
www.vekn.net/2-uncategorised/433-vampire-elder-kindred-network-newsletter-april-2019
Q: What is the "block resolution"?
A: If a minion is blocked, the block resolves by locking the blocking minion, and making the acting and blocking minion enter combat with each other. The "lock + enter combat" part is called the block resolution, and locking and entering combat happen at the same time.
Obedience is played "if this vampire is about to enter combat with an acting younger vampire" (that is, right before entering combat). If the "enter combat" is part of a block resolution (e.g., the vampire attempts to block and is about to be successful), the card is played and ends the action before the "lock + enter combat" block resolution: therefore, the blocking vampire is not locked.
Change of Target is played "if this minion is blocked, before block resolution." Since Change of Target ends the action, the block resolution never happens. Therefore, the blocking minion is not locked for blocking. (It would require explicit card text such as Mirror Walk that says: "lock the blocking minion and end the action before block resolution").
I have updated the rulebook.
www.vekn.net/2-uncategorised/433-vampire-elder-kindred-network-newsletter-april-2019
Q: What is the "block resolution"?
A: If a minion is blocked, the block resolves by locking the blocking minion, and making the acting and blocking minion enter combat with each other. The "lock + enter combat" part is called the block resolution, and locking and entering combat happen at the same time.
Obedience is played "if this vampire is about to enter combat with an acting younger vampire" (that is, right before entering combat). If the "enter combat" is part of a block resolution (e.g., the vampire attempts to block and is about to be successful), the card is played and ends the action before the "lock + enter combat" block resolution: therefore, the blocking vampire is not locked.
Change of Target is played "if this minion is blocked, before block resolution." Since Change of Target ends the action, the block resolution never happens. Therefore, the blocking minion is not locked for blocking. (It would require explicit card text such as Mirror Walk that says: "lock the blocking minion and end the action before block resolution").
I have updated the rulebook.
Last edit: 28 May 2019 09:49 by Ankha.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Lönkka
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
28 May 2019 10:09 #95095
by Tadori
Replied by Tadori on topic What exactly is "Block resolution"
Thanks,
But to be honest name "block resolution" is very confusing, because its indicates (as in every card game I played in 20 year) end of block action.
But to be honest name "block resolution" is very confusing, because its indicates (as in every card game I played in 20 year) end of block action.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
28 May 2019 11:31 - 28 May 2019 11:32 #95098
by Ankha
What other games are you referring to?
Replied by Ankha on topic What exactly is "Block resolution"
"Action resolution" is not the end of the action. "Block resolution" is not the end of the block. Unless you mean "after xxx resolution"?Thanks,
But to be honest name "block resolution" is very confusing, because its indicates (as in every card game I played in 20 year) end of block action.
What other games are you referring to?
Last edit: 28 May 2019 11:32 by Ankha.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
28 May 2019 12:38 - 28 May 2019 14:38 #95099
by Tadori
Hi This are examples form MTG
304.2. When an instant spell resolves, the actions stated in its rules text are followed. Then it’s put into its owner’s graveyard
When a sorcery spell resolves, the actions stated in its rules text are followed. Then it’s put into its owner’s graveyard
So resolution in MTG means you have to play an interrupt before resolution(you build stack) and reaction after resolution
This is from L5R
Each time a triggering condition occurs, the following sequence is followed: (1) execute any interrupts to that triggering condition, (2) resolve the triggering condition itself, and then, (3) execute any reactions to that triggering condition.
So looking at this examples. you have sequence of action.
1 play interparts (before [action] happens)
2 action resolution
3.reactions (after [action] happens)
So in our example our action is Block
Its starts with announcing block attempted(you can play interrupts), then we resolve "block" and the combat is the part of block action.When the combat ends Block segment resolves.(you can play reactions cards)
I understand your explanation and its ok. but the wording itself is a little not intuitive
Maybe "Before Block attempt resolution" would be bether. Then you have:
1.Block Action:
1.1 declare block attempt
1.1.1 Play Stealth/Intercept modifiers and card before “block attempt resolution” (action window)
1.2 Block attempt resolution (lock + begin combat)
1.3 combat
1.4 Block action resolution
Replied by Tadori on topic What exactly is "Block resolution"
"Action resolution" is not the end of the action. "Block resolution" is not the end of the block. Unless you mean "after xxx resolution"?Thanks,
But to be honest name "block resolution" is very confusing, because its indicates (as in every card game I played in 20 year) end of block action.
What other games are you referring to?
Hi This are examples form MTG
304.2. When an instant spell resolves, the actions stated in its rules text are followed. Then it’s put into its owner’s graveyard
When a sorcery spell resolves, the actions stated in its rules text are followed. Then it’s put into its owner’s graveyard
So resolution in MTG means you have to play an interrupt before resolution(you build stack) and reaction after resolution
This is from L5R
Each time a triggering condition occurs, the following sequence is followed: (1) execute any interrupts to that triggering condition, (2) resolve the triggering condition itself, and then, (3) execute any reactions to that triggering condition.
So looking at this examples. you have sequence of action.
1 play interparts (before [action] happens)
2 action resolution
3.reactions (after [action] happens)
So in our example our action is Block
Its starts with announcing block attempted(you can play interrupts), then we resolve "block" and the combat is the part of block action.When the combat ends Block segment resolves.(you can play reactions cards)
I understand your explanation and its ok. but the wording itself is a little not intuitive
Maybe "Before Block attempt resolution" would be bether. Then you have:
1.Block Action:
1.1 declare block attempt
1.1.1 Play Stealth/Intercept modifiers and card before “block attempt resolution” (action window)
1.2 Block attempt resolution (lock + begin combat)
1.3 combat
1.4 Block action resolution
Last edit: 28 May 2019 14:38 by Tadori.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
29 May 2019 10:30 - 29 May 2019 10:31 #95118
by Ankha
Block attempts are not part of the block resolution.
Announcing the action, playing cards as the action is played, attempting to block etc. are not part of the action resolution.
The (very) basic summary of an action is:
1/ declare the action and lock the minion
2/ play cards "as the action is announced"
3/ play action modifiers / reaction cards and declare block attempts
If the action is not blocked:
3'/ play more action modifiers / reaction cards
4/ resolve the action successfully ("action resolution")
If the action is blocked:
4/ resolve the action unsuccessfully => resolve the block ("block resolution")
Then in both case:
5/ play cards "after action resolution"
Replied by Ankha on topic What exactly is "Block resolution"
So looking at this examples. you have sequence of action.
1 play interparts (before [action] happens)
2 action resolution
3.reactions (after [action] happens)
So in our example our action is Block
Its starts with announcing block attempted(you can play interrupts), then we resolve "block" and the combat is the part of block action.When the combat ends Block segment resolves.(you can play reactions cards)
Block attempts are not part of the block resolution.
Announcing the action, playing cards as the action is played, attempting to block etc. are not part of the action resolution.
In VTES, "resolution" means the same as in other games, that is "304.2. When <here action card> resolves, the actions stated in its rules text are followed. Then it’s put into its owner’s graveyard"I understand your explanation and its ok. but the wording itself is a little not intuitive
Maybe "Before Block attempt resolution" would be bether. Then you have:
1.Block Action:
1.1 declare block attempt
1.1.1 Play Stealth/Intercept modifiers and card before “block attempt resolution” (action window)
1.2 Block attempt resolution (lock + begin combat)
1.3 combat
1.4 Block action resolution
The (very) basic summary of an action is:
1/ declare the action and lock the minion
2/ play cards "as the action is announced"
3/ play action modifiers / reaction cards and declare block attempts
If the action is not blocked:
3'/ play more action modifiers / reaction cards
4/ resolve the action successfully ("action resolution")
If the action is blocked:
4/ resolve the action unsuccessfully => resolve the block ("block resolution")
Then in both case:
5/ play cards "after action resolution"
Last edit: 29 May 2019 10:31 by Ankha.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.103 seconds
- You are here:
-
Home
-
Forum
-
V:TES Discussion
-
Rules Questions
- What exactly is "Block resolution"