Heaven's Gate vs Charigger the Axe
15 Aug 2023 09:32 - 15 Aug 2023 09:39 #109037
by lip
Heaven's Gate vs Charigger the Axe was created by lip
A has Ossian in play and a vampire with 
, B has a vampire with Charigger, The Axe. Ossian burns in combat. Can A play Heaven's Gate before Charigger's ability triggers?
1. It depends on who's acting (Sequencing)
2. No, Charigger's ability always takes precedence
Relevant rulings: [ANK 20210627] [LSJ 20071003]
Note that it's clear that both (as replacement effects) have precedence over effects that depend on the minion burning (eg. Kherebutu and other mummies)
, B has a vampire with Charigger, The Axe. Ossian burns in combat. Can A play Heaven's Gate before Charigger's ability triggers?1. It depends on who's acting (Sequencing)
2. No, Charigger's ability always takes precedence
Relevant rulings: [ANK 20210627] [LSJ 20071003]
Note that it's clear that both (as replacement effects) have precedence over effects that depend on the minion burning (eg. Kherebutu and other mummies)
Heaven's Gate
Prevent 1 damage to an ally in combat.
As 
Charigger, The Axe
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
16 Aug 2023 05:45 #109057
by Ankha
Replied by Ankha on topic Heaven's Gate vs Charigger the Axe
Correct.It should first depend on the impulse and second on the chosen sequencing.
I compare it with the question "Who is allowed to announce a block ignoring the regular restrictions first". It is not Anneke by default, it is the player who gets the impulse first.
Thus if player A were acting/had the impulse he could play "Heaven's Gate" before the effect of "Charigger, The Axe", and if player B were acting/had the impulse then the effect of "Charigger, The Axe" would kick in first.
And a player controlling both a Vampire with Obeah and "Charigger, The Axe" should be allowed to choose if he wished to play "Heaven's Gate" before the effect of "Charigger, The Axe" kicks in.
Prince of Paris, France
Ratings Coordinator, Rules Director
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.105 seconds
- You are here:
-
Home
-
Forum
-
V:TES Discussion
-
Rules Questions
- Heaven's Gate vs Charigger the Axe