"As Played" Window Ruling Contradictions?

Pascal wrote:

nc-italy wrote:

Pascal wrote:

Wake with Evening's Freshness + sup' Evil Eye to cancel an action card.
On the Qui Vive + sup' Evil Eye works, but remember that, in the "as played" window, cards aren't replaced (as written in the rulebook and in your first link).

So, basically, you if you wake, say, during the "as played" window to cancel a card you will replace a forced awakening only after you play a rewind time (already in your hand) to cancel an action card with it?
Seems rather odd (to replace a card only after playing another card in the
given "as played" window - to better clear to me "as played" should just
correspond to -> "as replaced" with no other utter windows in between)

You're not reading it the right way.

Rulebook wrote:

Some effects can cancel a card "as it is played." These effects (and effects that grant the ability to play them, like Forced Awakening) are the only effects allowed during the "as played" time period of another card. Even drawing to replace cards comes after this time period.

You can play Forced Awakening, but you won't replace it until after the 'as played' window closes. This is not related to the fact that you have an Evil Eye in your hand.

jamesatzephyr wrote:

nc-italy wrote:

I've read carefully and in fact i find odd the rule (as stated, to me "as played should correspond to an "as replaced" with no other rule window delaying the play/replace process, other than explicit card text ("do not replace until..."))

There need to be at least two distinct steps here.

First, you play the card. When you play it,

nc-italy wrote:

jamesatzephyr wrote:

nc-italy wrote:

I've read carefully and in fact i find odd the rule (as stated, to me "as played should correspond to an "as replaced" with no other rule window delaying the play/replace process, other than explicit card text ("do not replace until..."))

There need to be at least two distinct steps here.

First, you play the card. When you play it,

About "you play a card" rulebook also states:Drawing Cards. Whenever you play a library card from your hand, you immediately draw another from your library to replace it

"immediately" lead to some misunderstandings given the other rule cited ("cancel as it played") in the timing window "as played"

To be clearer, as much as you can't use a drawn-sudden-via-barrens to cancel a master card being played, imho there's should be no chanche on the "as played" window of playing a reaction card to wake and *then* another reaction to cancel another card
Also, i find the other rule somewhat odd and little conflicting with the other rulebook sentence about "immediately replacing the card" , which can lead to some misunderstandings