Should Hag's Wrinkles have an errata?

angrynewb wrote:

i think we can and should use our past experience with Una decks. and not wait until the car crashes before we fix it. i also dont think the Una change was because of its great success in tournaments or because you would see it so often. maybe someone with Una errata experience can chime in and explain why Una needed errata, but Hesha deck would be fine.

Not to mention that the Una fix felt "clumsy" IMHO, as also Ankara Citadel was changed instead of just making Freak Drive to "burn a blood to untap" ...

"Maybe because the Hag's Wrinkles deck hasn't really been proven to be problematic yet?"

That is what i was trying to explain to you. it is basically the same thing. you go through your whole deck while the other players wait to get another turn. the only reason why its not proven "problematic" is because only Sergio is playing it. and he is super fast. (he is also super fast with Una). but when more mediocore players try to play it, you will get those 40-50min turns again.

The errata for Una wasn't due to lots of Una decks winning tournaments (I think there is only 1 in the TWDA, it was for having one player using half of the time of the round in one turn while the other players just look at it.

I watch the Atlantic Cup final and Sergio played very fast, the problem might come when other players would start playing the deck, exactly as it happened with Una.

Maybe it is not an errata that needs to be done straight away, but I think to have the card in the watchlist of cards that can hace an errata.

angrynewb wrote:

"Maybe because the Hag's Wrinkles deck hasn't really been proven to be problematic yet?"

That is what i was trying to explain to you. it is basically the same thing. you go through your whole deck while the other players wait to get another turn. the only reason why its not proven "problematic" is because only Sergio is playing it. and he is super fast. (he is also super fast with Una). but when more mediocore players try to play it, you will get those 40-50min turns again.

And prey tell where are these hordes of mediocre players playing the deck then?

At least they don't seem to have materialized in these past weeks/ months. Which still leads me to the conclusion that there actually is so far NO Empiric evidence supporting the claim for errata.

Una was consistently doing finals and impacting them even if not winning at the end. I think more than the time spent, it was the NPE effect the problem.

Also with Pentex errata, Una would probably have been the best deck around

If every time an obscure combo worked a few times I yelled about banning cards, my personal ban list would be mostly thing's everyone forgets exist.

I'm not seeing a sizeable problem here hags wrinkles aren't as strong as British Museum. Or like most playable cards in the game.