Ashur Tablet killer

So I discussed this card with a friend. And I think we got some way with it. And note it is designed to weaken Ashur decks.

Hidden Past
Event - Inconnu
Each time a methuselah places a card in his library, he must burn a pool or a blood/life from a minion/retainer.

Note: This will also work against Heart of Cheat.

Baaliprimogen wrote:

So I discussed this card with a friend. And I think we got some way with it. And note it is designed to weaken Ashur decks.

Hidden Past
Event - Inconnu
Each time a methuselah places a card in his library, he must burn a pool or a blood/life from a minion/retainer.

Note: This will also work against Heart of Cheat.

An awful card that does nothing but destroy several fun, interesting, strong cards that are balanced-enough that they aren't in need of nerfing.

Baaliprimogen wrote:

Hidden Past
Event - Inconnu
Each time a methuselah places a card in his library, he must burn a pool or a blood/life from a minion/retainer.

I get the feeling you haven't thought this through all that well. Does Summon Soul really need to be nerfed into nonplayability?

This isn't really any worse than how totally Scourge of the Enochians kill any strategy relying on weenies/embraces, and I haven't seen anyone crying about how that card is too powerful.

Klaital wrote:

This isn't really any worse than how totally Scourge of the Enochians kill any strategy relying on weenies/embraces, and I haven't seen anyone crying about how that card is too powerful.

'Cept me, I think scourge is total BS.

If Ashurs are a problem, which I'm not entirely certain about as it seems only the extra-MPA cheese decks can use them without worrying about wasting the MPA's on nothing (I mean to say that's a problem), I'd think more cards that attack the ash heap are in order. Let's say something like a bleed card that does the same bleed as some other card but at superior removes as many cards as the amount of bleed. Would you use that? Trochomancy is somewhat similar but it's also used because it's the only bleed modifier for Harbringer disciplines.

AT isn't that strong in it's self. But the combo with liquadation makes it insane. Remember memories of mortality. That card wasn't that strong in it's self. But in combo with the imbued it was overpowered.

And come on, how many times do you see Summon soul in play? You may still play it, it only foster 2 more blood. And heart is stupid. It's way to usefull for a card that does not require anything.