"As Played" Window Ruling Contradictions?

Reyda wrote:

I am also in favor of simplifying things

The main problem being that people differ on what actually simplify things. As bare bone, there is a side that believe a stack would actually make thoses ruling simpler, and another one who feel the exact opposite.

I am not sure this can be argued : at this point it tend to go down to taste.

@Anka: I ll try to write it down in next few days if a get a chance.