Winged Second

wesile wrote:

Hum... if the WS gargoyle has a Sengir Dagger or some other agg weapon can we play Rothschreck?

No.
So, it gets played on Arika when the Gargoyle strikes with the Sengir Dagger. Except that requires the Gargoyle to be an opposing minion.

The Gargoyle WS isn't in combat and isn't an opposing minion, except to the extent provided for on the card text of Winged Second (dodge and damage prevention).

[LSJ 20070820]

LSJ wrote:

John's answers are correct except as amended below:
>> - If A is a vampire, Vampire C isn't "opposite vampire" to vampire A,
>> so Rötschreck cannot be played on C if A attempts to deal aggravated
>> damage to C. For the same reason, Rötschreck cannot be played on
>> Vampire A if C attempts to deal aggravated damage to A.
>
> Correct. C is not in the combat, and does not count for any effect
> that target a minion 'in combat' or 'the opposing minion'.

With no amendment.

In the scenario constructed by the questioner (Pascal), A is the acting vampire and C is the flight-y WS vampire.