Shadow Court Satyr ruling reversal?

I have now read the entire thread (again, had read it in the past) and I would say that if anything it makes it clear that “During” and “Once each” are NOT equivalents.

Furthermore, the thread is about “During X, do Y” and that Y is limited to once per X which people were trying to argue that “Once during each X, do Y” would be clearer.

Nowhere does the thread go into that “Once each” implies involvement is required.

If there is a specific portion that you think enforces and explains your point please quote it here.

inm8 wrote:

I have now read the entire thread (again, had read it in the past) and I would say that if anything it makes it clear that “During” and “Once each” are NOT equivalents.

Furthermore, the thread is about “During X, do Y” and that Y is limited to once per X which people were trying to argue that “Once during each X, do Y” would be clearer.

Nowhere does the thread go into that “Once each” implies involvement is required.

If there is a specific portion that you think enforces and explains your point please quote it here.

This is quite easy to solve, the Text of Fatima

of the past and present matches the *current* text of shadow court satyr. Aka the "once each combat, do x".

Question therefore is, can Fatima equip with a weapon from hand if they're not involved in combat?

If they can, then the current wording for the Shadow Court Satyr enables to use the effect "as if from hand" during combats they're not involved in. After all, that's the same trigger. If they cannot, then SCS cannot behave like a vampire and play a combat card.

And for good measure, let's throw White Lily in as well,
so we do not need to argue whether or not "Once each combat" and " Once per combat" work differently.

I'm not after changing the functions of cards. I want the card text to be able to speak for itself only supported by the rules.

If they aren´t supposed to be able to do it during any combat I think the appropriate action is to errata their text to reflect that and not to make up a new term/template where "Once each combat" and "Once per combat" implies involvement (especially as others similar e.g "Once each action" and "Once each turn" means all actions and turns respectively).